ETF overlap: why five funds can be one portfolio
· 6 min read
As of October 2026. Company weights come from public sources linked at the bottom. This is analysis, not investment advice: what you hold is your decision, ideally with a qualified adviser.
Your Interactive Brokers statement shows five tickers: an S&P 500 fund, a Nasdaq-100 fund, a world fund, a technology fund and another large-cap US fund. It looks like five separate bets. In practice, you will probably find the same handful of companies inside every one of them. That is overlap.
What ETF overlap is
Overlap happens when several funds hold the same stocks. The number of funds in the portfolio stays the same, but real diversification is lower than it looks. Sharesight describes it as ETFs "doubling or even tripling down" on the same underlying assets.
The cause is simple. Most popular indexes are weighted by market capitalisation: the bigger the company, the bigger its share. Large technology companies therefore sit at the top of almost every broad US fund, and a technology fund adds more of them.
How big it gets: the S&P 500 example
These are the weights of the three largest companies in SPY, the S&P 500 fund, from early October 2026 (24/7 Wall St, citing SPY's own holdings):
- Nvidia: 8.63%
- Apple: 7.25%
- Microsoft: 5.82%
Together that is 21.70%, and the top ten holdings make up 39.27%. About a fifth of a 500-company fund sits in three names. Weights change daily, so take fresh numbers from the fund page before you do your own maths.
Here is what that means for a portfolio. The numbers below are made up for illustration. Say 60% of your portfolio is in an S&P 500 fund. From that fund alone, your Nvidia share is about 0.6 × 8.63% ≈ 5.2% of the whole portfolio. If a Nasdaq-100 or technology fund sits next to it, Nvidia is near the top of that one too, and your share rises again. You never bought Nvidia directly, yet you own it in several places.
Where overlap shows up most
Two funds on the same index
CSPX and VOO both track the S&P 500. They differ in domicile and tax treatment, not in holdings. Hold both and you own one fund in two wrappers.
A broad fund plus a themed fund
Sharesight gives an example with three US funds: one on the S&P 500, one on the Nasdaq-100 and one on large-cap growth stocks. They look like the broad market, tech leaders and growth. Their top holdings overlap heavily, so the combined Big Tech exposure is well above what each fund suggests. A technology fund added to an S&P 500 fund works the same way.
A world fund plus a US fund
A world fund (VWRA, VT and similar) already contains US companies, and they carry a large weight in global indexes. Adding an S&P 500 fund raises your US share and the weight of the same giants. That can be a deliberate choice. The difficulty is that without a calculation you cannot see it.
Single stocks next to ETFs
If you bought several tech stocks directly and hold the rest in US funds, those companies stack on top of the funds. Each position looks small by itself, and together they can pass the limit you set for yourself.
Why it matters for your portfolio
- Concentration. One company can exceed 15% of your portfolio even though no single line item comes close. AlphaPulse checks a single stock against 15%, a sector against 35%, a country against 85% and cash against 10%, calculated from the fund contents rather than the tickers.
- One sector instead of five funds. If you work in tech and your portfolio leans on tech, that is one bet, not two. A sector sell-off hits your salary and your savings together.
- A false sense of diversification. The number of rows in a statement does not tell you how many different companies you own.
There is no rule for how much overlap is too much. Some investors are comfortable with higher concentration, others are not. What matters is knowing your own number.
How to check overlap yourself
By hand it takes an hour or two.
- List every fund you hold and its share of the portfolio.
- Open each fund's full holdings on the issuer's page.
- For each company, multiply its weight in the fund by the fund's share of your portfolio, and add the results across funds.
- Add any stocks you hold directly.
- Sort from largest to smallest and look at the top ten.
Use weights from the same date for every fund, or the numbers will not line up. That is why the manual method gets tedious beyond three funds. For Irish-domiciled UCITS funds, take the holdings from the iShares page or the issuer's own site.
The other route is to upload your statement to a tool that breaks funds into their components (look-through). AlphaPulse does exactly that. Export your IBKR statement (here is how) and in a few minutes you see which companies, sectors and countries are behind your tickers. The free check at /check needs no account.
What to do with the result
Only principles here, no specific funds.
If the result suits you, change nothing. Overlap is not a mistake, it is a property of indexes.
If concentration is higher than you planned, there are ways to restore balance. One needs no selling: direct new contributions to the parts that are under-weight until the mix evens out. That is rebalancing with contributions. It also avoids a tax event on a sale. Tax rules depend on where you live, so check them for your country of residence. For Ukrainian residents, as of October 2026, profit from selling securities is taxed at 18% income tax plus a 5% military levy, 23% in total; for personal cases ask a tax adviser.
Before adding a new fund, ask what it adds: new companies, or the same ones in different packaging.
A note for US persons
If you are a US taxpayer, PFIC rules apply to funds domiciled outside the US. Discuss them with a tax adviser before changing anything.