Rebalancing without selling: use new money before you trigger a tax bill
· 4 min read
As of October 2026. This article covers principles, not specific securities. It is not tax advice.
Say your plan is 60% in an equity fund and 40% in bonds. A year later equities have risen and you hold 70/30. The textbook fix is rebalancing: sell part of what grew and buy what shrank. In most countries that sale can create a taxable gain.
What a sale can cost
Tax depends on your country of residence, so check your own rules. For Ukrainian tax residents, DPS (as reported by Debet-Kredit) taxes foreign-source income at 18% personal income tax plus a 5% military levy, and the yankiv.com guide gives the same rates for gains on securities: 23% of the difference between sale and purchase price. Details are in our Interactive Brokers taxes article.
If you are a US person, the rules differ again, and non-US funds bring PFIC rules, so talk to a US tax adviser before choosing funds.
Example
The numbers are illustrative. Commissions, currency effects and local conversion rules are ignored.
Your portfolio is $50,000 with a 60% fund A / 40% fund B target. After A rises: $35,000 in A (70%), $15,000 in B (30%).
Option 1: sell some A. Moving $5,000 from A to B restores 60/40. If 40% of the sale is gain ($2,000) and the rate is 23%, the tax is $460.
Option 2: put new money into B. Leave A alone. For A to be 60% of the portfolio, the total must reach about $58,333, so you would deposit about $8,333, all into B. No sale, no tax event.
The honest limit: with a big drift and small deposits, one contribution does not close the gap. At $1,000 a month the example takes about eight months. For a drift of a few percentage points, one or two deposits are enough.
Three ways to rebalance without selling
1. Direct deposits to what is underweight
Each month compare actual weights with targets and add money where the weight is below target. Vanguard describes the same approach for investors with inflows: buy the underweight allocations first. It also notes that this reduces transaction costs.
2. Direct dividends the same way
Instead of reinvesting a dividend into the same fund, point it at the underweight one. We do not state dividend tax rates here because sources disagree.
3. Allow a tolerance band
Vanguard lists calendar, threshold or combined approaches and says research shows no particular advantage to any, so consistency matters most. A wider band means fewer trades. Pick a band, for example 5 percentage points from target, and act only when it is crossed.
When selling is still the answer
- The drift is large and no new money is coming.
- One stock or fund has grown so much that your risk no longer matches your plan. Vanguard frames rebalancing as risk management, not return optimisation.
- You are changing your targets.
Then count the tax in advance as the price of lowering risk, and ask an adviser how acquisition cost is computed in your case.
What to read from your statement
You need three numbers per holding: current value, target weight and current weight. If several ETFs hold the same companies inside, the real weights differ from the visible ones. Export your IBKR statement to get the values.
A five-minute monthly routine
- Export your latest statement or read current position values in IBKR.
- Compute each holding's weight: its value divided by the portfolio value.
- Compare with target. If every drift is inside your band, split the deposit as usual.
- If a holding is below target by more than the band, send the deposit and dividends there until it is back inside.
- Note the date and result. After six months you will see whether deposits are enough to keep you on plan or whether a sale is on the table.
Transfers from a bank or a payment service to your broker take time and may carry fees, so plan the deposit ahead instead of on the day you notice the drift.
How AlphaPulse helps
AlphaPulse reads your IBKR statement, shows what you really hold through ETFs and flags where weights are off its limits. Smart Top-Up (Pro, ₴450 a month, see pricing) builds a buy-only plan for your next deposit among positions you already hold. It is analytics, not advice to buy a particular security. The free check needs no sign-up.